Manage Learn to apply best practices and optimize your operations.

QLogic Throws Curve Ball in Fibre Channel Plans

QLogic throws a curve ball.

This article can also be found in the Premium Editorial Download: Storage magazine: Should you consolidate your direct-attached storage (DAS)?

Until recently, Fibre Channel's (FC) future seemed clear, if distant, with 10Gb/s connectivity coming around 2004,...

up from 2Gb/s today. But then QLogic--arguably one of the most important providers of FC silicon--announced that it would also develop 4Gb/s components.

Toe Cards
Want to do iSCSI, but the CPU hit your servers take got you down? A TCP/IP offload engine, or TOE card, might be the answer. Following are a few TOE cards on the market, some of which also offload the iSCSI protocol.
Adaptec ASA-7211 iSCSI card Single port 1 Gb Ethernet NIC with TCP/IP and iSCSI offload $627.26 (fiber optic)
$579.36 (copper)
Alacritech 100x1 Single Port Server Adapter Single port 10/100BASE-TX Fast Ethernet Network Interface Adapter (NIC) with TCP/IP offload $349.57
Intel PRO 1000 T IP Storage Adapter Single port 1Gb Ethernet TCP/IP and iSCSI NIC and accelerator $567.01

To clarify, 4Gb/s FC has always been on the roadmap for the back end, i.e., between controllers and disk drives. But for FC switches and host bus adapters (HBAs), the next stop along the road has long been 10Gb/s.

What's QLogic doing? For one, 10Gb/s FC isn't backward compatible with existing fabrics. "That was a big surprise to everyone we talked to," says Frank Berry, QLogic VP of corporate marketing. Second, if the price of 10Gb/s Ethernet is any indication--Intel's 10GbE network interface card, the PRO/10GbE LR Server Adapter has a list price of $7,995--10Gb/s FC will be very costly. In contrast, QLogic expects to be able to sell 4Gb/s ports at about the same price as 2Gb/s. Lastly, because work on 4Gb/s back end components is already well underway, "we didn't really have to do anything," Berry says.

"It's a matter of economics, really," says Randy Kerns, senior partner at the Evaluator Group. "Six months ago, I would have told you, 'This won't happen,' but now it seems like it will."

QLogic will obviously support 4Gb/s in future generations of its switches, but so far, it doesn't look like market leaders Brocade and McData will follow suit.

Brocade, for one, is on the fence. "The need to accommodate 4G[b] in a switched fabric is unclear," says a Brocade spokesperson, and "is actively working to understand if a sufficient level of end user application performance can be realized from 4G[b] fabric speed."

McData's Mike Tomky, senior product marketing manager, is more direct: "We will not stop at 4Gb/s." Why not? "There's no demand for 4Gb/s--customers are barely using up the 2Gb/s ports they already have. The only burning need they have for additional bandwidth is in ISLs [inter-switch links]," which McData will fill with 10Gb/s ports.

This was last published in June 2003

Dig Deeper on SAN technology and arrays

Start the conversation

Send me notifications when other members comment.

By submitting you agree to receive email from TechTarget and its partners. If you reside outside of the United States, you consent to having your personal data transferred to and processed in the United States. Privacy

Please create a username to comment.