Problem solve Get help with specific problems with your technologies, process and projects.

Director vs. switch

Storage expert Greg Schulz outlines things to consider when choosing switches for a SAN.

I'm having difficulty comparing directors to switches. Which is better? What are the advantages of each one?

Without knowing what your storage area network (SAN) requirements and objectives are, it would be inappropriate to make a recommendation or say if a Fibre Channel (FC) director or switch would be more advantageous for you. In general, the differences between a FC director and switch go much further than simply the number of ports and physical packaging. It used to be that you could distinguish a switch from a director based upon the protocols supported -- for example FICON on a director. However, some switches support both FCP and FICON. Likewise, it used to be that you could distinguish a switch from a director via the number of ports and presence of removable blades. However, that has changed with large port count switches, stackable switches and blade switches.

In general, a director will have more scalability in terms of number and types of ports, protocols and interfaces (types of blades), overall performance, redundancy and perhaps partitioning or other advanced resiliency features. Avoid the temptation to replace several switches with a single director. Instead, for high availability, deploy a pair of directors as separate fabric and data access paths. They key is to identify what your needs and requirements are in terms of performance, protocols and interfaces, number of ports, topology and availability among others and align the applicable technology to meet those needs.

I'm sure Brocade, Cisco, McData and Qlogic would be more than happy to help educate you on their particularly switches, blade switch, stackable switches, directors and router products. You can also learn more about switches and directors including how and where to deploy them in Chapter 7 (Storage networking devices), Chapter 8 (Storage Network Design) and Chapter 9 (Storage Networking Topologies) of my book "Resilient Storage Networks" (Elsevier).

Dig Deeper on SAN technology and arrays