There are some things you should think twice about before buying used: mattresses, running shoes and backup tapes. But according to Jim Milligan, executive director of sales and marketing at Imation, which makes tape media, buying and selling used tape media is becoming more common.
"IT folks under operational cost pressures are reselling tapes into the recertified market," Milligan says, usually at the suggestion of a VAR who offers to take old tapes in exchange for a credit toward future purchases. Those tapes are then erased, repackaged and resold, usually at a discount of 20% to 50% over brand-new tapes.
However, backup tapes don't always erase well. Imation engineers recently purchased four recertified LTO cartridges and could see enough residual signal to determine that the tapes had been used by an R&D facility researching DNA sequences, Milligan says.
That highlights the risk of selling your used tapes. "Is the information on them truly being eliminated and destroyed?" Milligan asks. That's an especially valid question in regulated industries like finance and healthcare, which have strict privacy provisions Bob Abraham, president of Freeman Reports, a market research firm focused on removable media, concurs. "We've all heard stories of tapes and disks getting erased, but the data is still there. If there's sensitive data on the tape, the only safe thing to do is shred it."
Buyers of used backup tapes run different risks, mainly around reliability.
Buyers often don't know they're buying recertified tapes because they're repackaged and boxed to look like new tapes. There are obvious signs--catchphrases like "refurbished" or "recycled," but vendors will sometimes obfuscate a tape's used status with sneakier descriptors like "factory certified" or "better-than-new." To remove that uncertainty, Imation is developing a security seal for its new cartridges that will immediately identify a tape as new.
Denigrating used tapes is an easy position for a media manufacturer to take, but Abraham believes the risks Milligan describes are real. "It's a legitimate position. The fact that they may be trying to protect their market is besides the point."
This was first published in September 2005