This article can also be found in the Premium Editorial Download "Storage magazine: Comparing the top data backup packages."

Download it now to read this article plus other related content.

Veritas recently released Backup Exec 9.0, the latest iteration of an application with a long history. Veritas also has a family of backup applications--its flagship product NetBackup was reviewed in Storage magazine (see "Veritas raises the bar with NetBackup 4.5").

Requires Free Membership to View

Industry analysts predicted Backup Exec might be folded into NetBackup, in the same way that Computer Associates (CA) folded its disparate ARCserve/Cheyenne Software acquisitions into BrightStor Enterprise editions. Instead, Veritas put its full support behind both the legacy and the future of Backup Exec 9.0. That sort of vendor panache warrants a review.

Our test platform
We developed a test platform that was used to test not only Backup Exec, but several different backup application platforms in future issues. While in no way empirical, the prototype/sample enterprise platform represents a cross-platform representation of what many readers have in their data centers.

A hybrid Gigabit Ethernet/Fast Ethernet infrastructure was developed utilizing three types of network operating system platforms, along with five types of clients. We added four major popular host applications to the mix: Microsoft Exchange 2000, Microsoft SQL Server 2000, Oracle 9i, and Lotus Domino. Oracle 9i and Lotus Domino are installed on Windows 2000 Advanced Server and Linux.

The network operating system hosts included UnitedLinux (as released by SuSE) Microsoft Windows 2000 Advanced Server (SP3 and revs. to Jan. 2003) and Apple's Xserve OS/X 10.2.3. Unfortunately, Xserve support is sparse, and done as a client with Backup Exec 9.0 at best. Clients chosen included Windows 98SE, Windows 2000 Professional; Windows XP Professional, Apple OS/X 10.2 and Linux 2.4 (SuSE 8.1). We patched all server, client and application platforms to recommended levels as of December 2002.

We used a Compaq DL580 server (four 1.8GHz Xeon CPUs) as the Windows 2000 Advanced Server platform. The DL580 contained 8GB of DRAM, two internal SCSI drives (of four possible) and an Emulex 2FC 9000 series adapter. The Emulex FC adapter in turn was connected to a JMR JBOD array. Linux testing was performed on a Compaq DL380 server (dual 733MHz CPUs) containing 2GB of DRAM and three internal SCSI drives. Two Apple Xserves (4GB DRAM, twin 833MHz PowerPC CPUs) containing four ATA100 drives, running OS/X 10.2.3 were also connected. Each server was connected to an Allied Telesyn GbE switch, and in turn to a Compaq GbE/Fast Ethernet switch to clients.

Backup Exec exists in an OEM form in most versions of Microsoft Windows--called backup.exe--starting with Windows 95. In Microsoft's server editions, Backup Exec is similar to the Unix/GNU Tape Archive (TAR), a minimalist application dependent on the host operating system for most of its actions. Veritas' Backup Exec was a platform that matured both on Microsoft Windows and Novell's NetWare.

Before the introduction of Windows 2000, backup hardware support in Windows server was--to put it kindly--quite weak. As a result, backup software vendors had to work closely with hardware storage vendors on compatibility issues or build drivers themselves. Veritas' relationship with Microsoft helped, but Veritas was caught in the same trap that other backup software makers were: revision synchronization problems.

The Windows 2000 server platform now seems to negate the need for combination-specific drivers, and Veritas depends on the Windows infrastructure exclusively for backup device compatibility. That's refreshing.

Where compatibility permitted, we attempted a full backup, then a bare metal restore to each server, client and then each application. We tested using StorageTek's T9940B running on a Windows 2000 Advanced Server to perform the common denominator backup of the platforms (server, MS Exchange, MS SQL Server, Oracle 9i/Windows, and Lotus Domino/Windows) after wiping all platforms clean.

We restarted an identical backup job afterwards, and then attempted a bare metal restore of a Windows client--which was contained on the same media--to see if the backup software was capable of backing up and restoring concurrently.

What we learned
We initially received "gold" software prior to the product's release. A subsequent comparison verified we had what you'll find in the market. Printed documentation wasn't available at test time, but wasn't really needed. This is a thoroughly wizard-driven product, although a command line interface is available.

Veritas' claim that Backup Exec can be installed in 10 minutes was no fabrication. We popped in the CD, answered a few questions and without rebooting, we had Backup Exec 9.0 ready to work.

Backup Exec 9.0 initially couldn't find our StorageTek T9940B tape drive. Tools included with Backup Exec 9.0 let us find the nature of the problem--a T9940B Windows driver installation problem. The problem was no fault of Backup Exec 9.0 since it no longer uses many specialized drivers and depends on Windows and a device's maker to stabilize communications. Veritas helped us find the problem.

The interface and infrastructure to Backup Exec 9.0 is highly centralized, and information on the Windows 2000 platform was intuitive and simple to find. The primary user interface is centralized, and can be accessed remotely via an add-on package, which wasn't tested.

This was first published in March 2003

There are Comments. Add yours.

TIP: Want to include a code block in your comment? Use <pre> or <code> tags around the desired text. Ex: <code>insert code</code>

REGISTER or login:

Forgot Password?
By submitting you agree to receive email from TechTarget and its partners. If you reside outside of the United States, you consent to having your personal data transferred to and processed in the United States. Privacy
Sort by: OldestNewest

Forgot Password?

No problem! Submit your e-mail address below. We'll send you an email containing your password.

Your password has been sent to: